You must play a secret song on the Water Harp in Remnant 2 to get the “Carnage in C-Minor” trophy or achievement. Solving this puzzle was enough of a pain the first time around, and there are even fewer clues this time. In fact, if you don’t have a good ear for music, you’ll find yourself struggling to find the Water Harp’s secret song.
How to play the Water Harp secret song in Remnant 2
You’ll play the Water Harp secret song in Remnant 2 by arranging eight rows of pins, just as you did the first time. Unfortunately, you won’t get a written clue for the secret song. However, finding the tune itself isn’t too hard.
After taking down the Ravager, return to Yaesha and visit the Flautist. You’ll notice that this time around, he’s playing a different tune. You’ll need to enter this secret song into the Water Harp.
Unfortunately, this is going to be quite the stumper for some players. Those that can discern a tune well won’t have any issues, but not everyone has that talent. Fortunately, we’ve got the simple solution for the Water Harp secret tune puzzle. Remember that you’re working with an 8×5 grid, and arrange the pins in the order below.
| Column/Row | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| 1 | X | ||||
| 2 | X | ||||
| 3 | |||||
| 4 | X | ||||
| 5 | X | ||||
| 6 | |||||
| 7 | X | ||||
| 8 |
You’ll know you’ve entered it correctly when pins pop out of the rest of the roll, and the tune keeps playing. You’ll get the Carnage in C-Minor trophy or achievement and another decent reward: the Bold Driver handgun. It fires a three-round burst and is relatively accurate, making it a worthy addition to your arsenal.
So, In Remnant 2, the Water Harp secret song puzzle can be solved by attentively listening to the Flautist’s tune. Following the provided pin arrangement on the 8×5 grid correctly yields the Carnage in C-Minor trophy and Bold Driver handgun.
