Unlockable Arenas
| Unlockable | How to Unlock |
|---|---|
| Armory | Defeat James Storm during Story Mode |
| England | Earn 420,000 Style Points |
| Freedom Center | Defeat Jobber Savage E in an Ultimate X Match during Story Mode |
| Japan | Defeat the Motor City Machine Guns during Story Mode |
| Mexico | Win the Mexican Gauntlet Match during Story Mode |
| Vegas | Defeat Kurt Angle during Story Mode |
Unlockable Wrestlers
| Unlockable | How to Unlock |
|---|---|
| Black Machismo | Defeat him in Story Mode. |
| Brother Ray | Defeat TEAM 3D in story mode. |
| Eric Young | During Story Mode, you will eventually be paired up with Eric Young. After successfully winning your first tag team match, he will be unlocked. |
| Jay Lethal | Defeat Lethal in your TNA tryout gauntlet match in story mode. |
| Jeff Jarrett | Defeat him in Story mode |
| Moves for your created superstar | Various moves are unlocked as your progress through story mode. |
| Suicide | Defeat Jeff Jarrett in Story mode |
| Tomko | Win the Tag Team Match |
