Characters
| Unlockable | How to Unlock |
|---|---|
| Brie Bella | Win one Women's Championship with any Diva on PPV (1-on-1) |
| Druids | Beat All 5 RTWM |
| ECW Championship Belt | Win WWE Championship in Main Event at Extreme Rules |
| Ezekiel Jackson | Win 5 matches on "WWE Superstars" with any superstar (1-on-1 Match only) |
| Finlay | Win 1 "SmackDown" match with any Superstar (1-on-1 Match only) |
| Gail Kim | Win 1 Divas-only match with any Diva |
| Goldust | Win 10 "Raw" matches with any Superstar (1-on-1 Match only) (WWE Universe) |
| Jake "The Snake" Roberts | Defeat him on Week 9 in Taker's RTWM without taking substantial damage |
| Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka | Beat Superfly on Week 10 in Taker's RTWM in under 3 minutes. |
| Masked Kane | Collect all the souls in Taker's RTWM and beat him on Week 11. |
| Mickie James | Win 5 Divas-only matches with any Diva (1-on-1 matches only) |
| Mike Knox | Win 5 "SmackDown" matches with any superstar (1-on-1 matches only) |
| Nikki Bella | Win one Women's Championshipwith any Diva on PPV (1-on-1 match) |
| Paul Bearer | After defeating Paul Bearer(in 90 sec), Defeat Undertaker at WrestleMania |
| Rob Van Dam | Unlockable after beating Rey Mysterio's RTWM. |
| Shelton Benjamin | Win 10 "SmackDown" matches with any superstar (1-on-1 matches only) |
| Stone Cold Steve Austin | Complete all 5 Challenge matches in Christian's RTWM and beat Austin at Wrestlemania. |
| The Rock | Complete all 5 Challenge matches in the "Vs Undertaker" RTWM and beat The Rock at Wrestlemania. |
| Vladimir Kozlov | Win 1 "RAW" match with any Superstar (1-on-1 Match only) |
| William Regal | Win 10 “WWE Superstars” match with any Superstar (1-on-1 match only) |
| Yoshi Tatsu | Win 5 “Raw” matches with any Superstar (1-on-1 match only) |
| Zack Ryder | Win 1 “WWE Superstars” match with any Superstar (1-on-1 match only) |
