Shogun: Total War Review

A most honorable effort.

I recently took a much needed vacation in New York. It wasn’t very long and

I had to get back to work right away, but great nonetheless. There was a lot

to see in the city, but I’d have to say that the Metropolitan Museum of Art

kicks major ass. Yes, a museum can kick ass.

If you’ve ever been there, you know it’s all about the theme rooms. One moment

you’re looking at paintings on the wall; the next, you find yourself in a giant

atrium with an Egyptian archway. Or there’s the Greek balcony that looks out over

a white pillared room of marble statues.

And then there’s the Japanese room. You’re suddenly transported to some eastern

tea garden. I kept waiting for the dojo master to come out and challenge me.

Like the theme rooms of the Met, Shogun: Total War is a “themed” real time strategy focusing on Feudal Japan. Japan has been separated into seven regions, each controlled by a Daimyo. You control one of these Daimyos on a campaign to become the leader of all Japan – to become the almighty Shogun.

Opening the box, I came upon a sheet of “corrections.” Seems like there were a

whole bunch of glaring and blaring omissions and mistakes in the instruction manual.

I couldn’t help but feel very wary about the game.

Thankfully, the game isn’t as screwed up as the instructions. In fact, things

turn out quite well. Shogun provides a good change of pace to the traditionally

more fantasy or sci-fi-based real time strategies. The historical grounding gives

it a different feel and admittedly, a slight power trip.

The Tutorial mode is a good place to start. A Miyagi-esque voice talks you through

the game’s play techniques and strategy. In addition to the useful economic systems

and resource planning in nearly all real time strategies, there are unit types,

including archers, spearmen and cavalry. The strategy herein works like a game

of Paper/Rock/Scissors, or as the Japanese call it, Jankenpo. For example, the

archers are strong against the slow moving spearmen, but weak against the power

of your cavalry. It’s a good system that keeps it from becoming nothing more than

chaotic fighting.

The seven different clans have unique attributes. Each clan occupies a different geographical region with its own strengths and weaknesses. In your campaign to take over, you have access to espionage and diplomacy functions, but these take a backseat to what we’re all here for: WAR!

The structured system behind the battles is turn-based. Before you step foot on

the battlefield, you play from a map overlooking the region of Japan you control.

You can see the different resources available to you and what armies are where.

From there, you can observe your rivals and decide what to move where, what to

build, and most importantly, who to conquer. It has a distinct war room feel.

While the gameplay

is interesting, Shogun could have worked harder at the little things to

make the whole experience much better. When you roll your mouse over an army unit,

for example, information is fed out about that army. Sometimes the color of the

font is just plain hard to read. Without an adequate contrasting color, it’s hard

to figure out the details on that specific army. Really hard.

Since the game is focused on war, diplomacy and espionage are more like orders that you send out and receive word back on – nothing especially involving, just cross your fingers and wait. And unless you are a master of hot keys, the interface will repeatedly annoy you.

Graphically, this is a mixed bag. There are particle effects of fog and snow,

and while the former looks good, the latter could have looked much better. Environmentally,

expect the rolling green hills and expansive plains that make up old school Japan.

It’s good, but not great. The soldiers don’t animate perfectly. However, the sense

of having giant armies sweeping across the countryside is genuinely there. Basically,

the graphics get the job done.

Musically, things sound appropriate and Japanese. You’ll hear plenty of those

giant Taiko drums and some old man yodeling in the background. I’m no expert on

the music of Japan, but it definitely has that feel. And what I really appreciate

is having everything spoken to me in Japanese. It does wonders for authenticity.

Shogun provides a refreshing change of pace for real-time strategists.

If you are deeply interested in Japanese history, you will appreciate this game

that much more.